Serving Superior today, and for the long run
The question of who owns Superior's water utility is important, and customers deserve accurate information about what a change in ownership could mean.
Who We Are
Superior Water, Light and Power Company, a wholly owned subsidiary of ALLETE, Inc., delivers electricity, natural gas, and water to customers in Superior, Wisconsin, and adjacent areas. We have served the city of Superior and surrounding areas in northwestern Wisconsin since 1889 and have 15,000 electric customers, 13,000 natural gas customers and 10,000 water customers.
By purchasing electricity at wholesale prices, we are able to combine reliable service with rates that are competitive in Wisconsin and nationally. Having connections to two interstate pipelines also provides for competitive rates and enhanced reliability for our natural gas system. Our water treatment system draws water from Lake Superior, provides high quality water to customers and has the capacity to serve large industrial water-users.
More than 130 years of serving Superior
15,000electric customers
13,000natural gas customers
10,000water customers
$20.7Minvested in Superior's water system since 2020
$275,000in local community support since 2020
Superior is our home, too. Our employees live and work here, and we're proud to serve this community. We remain committed to investing in the water system, supporting our customers and providing reliable service for generations to come.
We oppose the takeover of our water utility. Here’s why.
SWL&P has provided safe, reliable water service to the residents, businesses, schools and hospitals in the Superior community since 1889. Today, our water customers rely on our experienced and dedicated local employees and established systems for infrastructure, customer service, cybersecurity and other essential services already in place. We're proud to serve the community we call home.
The City is asking voters whether it should purchase SWL&P’s water system if the price, determined later by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSC), falls within the City’s financial means.
That means when voters cast their ballots, a crucial piece of information will be missing. Voters will have to decide “Yes” or “No” without knowing the actual cost to purchase the utility, including the final purchase price, transition costs and most importantly the full financial impact on customers. Furthermore, the question does not specify who decides whether the PSC’s valuation is within the City’s means, or by what standard.
At least one independent expert has estimated that acquiring the water system, separating it from existing operations and establishing a stand-alone utility could cost approximately $186 million, which does not include the costs to operate and maintain the system. Yet voters are being asked to authorize the takeover without knowing the final cost or having a guaranteed opportunity to weigh in once that cost is determined.
The City would take over the utility and all its assets through bonds repaid by residents over decades through taxes, water bills or both. The purchase itself does not guarantee new investment to maintain a safe, reliable system nor improved service. The City has also not explained how customers would be better off. Generations of Superior families have relied on this water system for safe, reliable service. The City's proposal would ask them to pay again for infrastructure that has been serving the community for decades.
The questions go beyond cost.
The City has not presented a complete plan for operating the water utility. Today, SWL&P’s water system is operated and maintained by skilled union members of IBEW Local 31 and supported by shared systems for billing, customer service, technology and other critical functions. Separating the water system from these shared services would be complex and costly. It's unclear who would operate the system or how the City would maintain safe, reliable service from day one.
SWL&P opposes the proposed takeover. It could mean higher costs, greater operational risks and more uncertainty for water customers.
Referendum Status
The Superior City Council has approved a referendum question concerning the potential acquisition of SWL&P’s water utility for the April 6, 2027 ballot. SWL&P has filed a lawsuit challenging the wording and legal effect of the referendum question and is seeking to prevent the language, as currently written, from appearing on the ballot.
SWL&P respects the City of Superior’s statutory rights to bring a utility takeover question to voters, but believes voters deserve a clear understanding of what they are being asked to decide.
The matter is now before the Douglas County Circuit Court. We will update this page as the legal process continues.
Frequently Asked Questions About the City’s Proposed Takeover
Superior voters are expected to see a referendum concerning the future ownership of the community’s water utility on the April 6, 2027 ballot. The Superior City Council approved revised referendum language on October 20, 2026.
We know customers may have questions about what the referendum asks, what is known today, and what would have to happen before ownership of the water utility could change. SWL&P is committed to providing clear, factual information as this process continues.
The City-approved ballot question states:
“Should the City of Superior acquire the water utility operated by Superior Water, Light and Power to become community-owned, if its value, as determined by the Wisconsin Public Service Commission, falls within the City's financial means?”
This is the exact revised language approved by the Superior City Council for the April 6 referendum.
A “Yes” vote would indicate support for the proposition stated in the referendum question. The City has indicated that a favorable vote would allow it to pursue a regulatory process before the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin to establish a value for SWL&P’s water utility.
No. The referendum itself would not transfer ownership or establish a final purchase price. Additional proceedings would be required to determine the value of the water utility, and significant financial, regulatory, legal, and operational steps would remain before any transfer of ownership could occur.
A “No” vote would indicate that the voter does not support the proposition presented in the referendum question.
The referendum itself would not transfer ownership of the water utility or establish a final purchase price. If the City continues pursuing an acquisition following the referendum, additional steps would be required, potentially including proceedings before the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin, determination of the water utility’s value, financing decisions, legal proceedings, negotiations and detailed planning to separate and transition the water utility from SWL&P’s existing operations.
Until an acquisition is completed, SWL&P remains responsible for operating the water utility and serving customers.
The Public Service Commission of Wisconsin has not reviewed a utility takeover since 1978, and the state has no established timeline for completing one. A referendum would represent only the beginning of the process. Substantial work would follow, including asset valuation, financing, legal and regulatory proceedings, and operational transition planning.
Although each state’s process differs, experience across the country points to a consistent outcome that involuntary takeovers typically take years to resolve, and the extended timeline drives costs higher.
The referendum currently proposed for April occurs before the final value of the water utility is known. The City has not committed to holding a second referendum after a value is determined.
This means voters could be asked to express their support for the acquisition before knowing the final purchase price, financing costs, or total customer impact.
No. A national expert in utility valuation estimated approximately $186 million in initial costs associated with acquiring the system, separating it from SWL&P's other operations and establishing a stand-alone water utility. The City's referendum consultant has appraised the water system's operating assets at approximately $58 million.
Ultimately the fair market value of the water utility would be set by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin in a regulatory process that could take years to establish.
City of Superior, WI Water Municipalization Preliminary Feasibility Study
Yes. A purchase price is only one component of a potential acquisition. Depending on the structure of a transaction, additional costs could include financing, legal and regulatory proceedings, transition expenses, technology and billing systems, cybersecurity, staffing, separation of shared facilities and services, and future capital investment.
The amount of these costs would depend upon the final acquisition and operating plan.
Figure I-3 below from Concentric’s feasibility study estimates what the total costs could be.
The referendum question uses the phrase “falls within the City's financial means,” but it does not define a dollar amount or financial threshold for that term.
That means voters may reasonably want to understand:
- What purchase price the City considers affordable
- How an acquisition would be financed
- How much debt would be required
- Applicable interest rates and financing costs
- How acquisition debt would be repaid
- What additional transition costs would be incurred
- What future capital investments would be required
These are separate questions from the value ultimately assigned to the utility. The referendum question itself does not establish a maximum acquisition price.
No. SWL&P cannot set water rates on its own. The Public Service Commission of Wisconsin reviews and approves water rates to ensure they are reasonable. This oversight applies whether a water utility is privately or city owned.
No. Regardless of ownership, customers must ultimately support the costs of operating, maintaining, and investing in the water system.
A stand-alone water utility would need qualified personnel and systems to support water production and distribution, maintenance, engineering, emergency response, customer service, billing, regulatory compliance, technology and cybersecurity, among other functions.
The City has not yet presented a complete staffing and transition plan identifying which employees and shared services would be needed to operate the water system independently.
Questions about staffing and shared services have already been raised publicly during the City's consideration of the referendum.
That remains an important unresolved issue.
Employees and representatives of IBEW Local 31 raised concerns during the City's September public hearing about staffing, shared services and which employees would be needed to operate a stand-alone City water utility.
Yes. The referendum concerns the water utility. SWL&P would continue providing electric and natural gas service to its customers.
SWL&P's three utilities currently leverage economies of scale - shared employees, technology, equipment, billing, customer service, and other support functions. Separating the water utility would require detailed transition planning, and economies of scale would be reduced.
No. Under SWL&P ownership, all costs associated with this transaction are being paid for by shareholders, are not part of current rates, and will not be incorporated into any future rates.
SWL&P filed a lawsuit in Douglas County Circuit Court challenging the wording and legal effect of the referendum question. SWL&P believes such an important question should be clear, not vague and misleading. We want our customers to have direct and accurate information about this issue. The lawsuit asks the court to determine that the question, as currently written, does not comply with Wisconsin Law.
[Placeholder: Add link to complaint.]
No. Fees associated with the referendum lawsuit are not part of current rates and will not be incorporated into future rates.
Yes, SWL&P is supporting the Superior Community Coalition and their efforts to oppose the takeover, because we believe this proposal is not in the best interest of our customers. Any contributions associated with the Superior Community Coalition are not part of current rates and will not be incorporated into future rates. Additionally, all SWL&P contributions are disclosed in campaign financing compliance reports.
We’re Investing in Superior
Serving Superior means planning for the future, maintaining the infrastructure our community relies on and helping customers access the resources they need.
Helping customers manage costs today
SWL&P offers programs and resources that can help customers manage utility costs, including payment assistance, flexible payment options and energy-conservation resources.
Water Residential Assistance Program (WRAP)
Investing in safe, reliable water
SWL&P is working to replace lead water service lines throughout Superior. In 2024, we completed an initial inventory of every water service line to help identify where replacements are needed.
In 2025, SWL&P supported legislation that became Wisconsin Act 8. That law made private water utilities eligible for principal forgiveness through Wisconsin's Safe Drinking Water Loan Program for lead service line replacement. This expanded access to funding was previously unavailable to customers of private water utilities, including those served by SWL&P in Superior.
To date, this law change has brought over $7.0 million to the benefit of customers in Superior.
Our Commitment to Customers
The question of who owns Superior's water utility is important, and customers deserve accurate information about what a change in ownership could mean.
As the April referendum approaches, SWL&P will continue to provide information about the process, costs and questions involved while remaining focused on our responsibility today: providing safe, reliable water service to the Superior community, just as we have done for the last 130 years.
We're already here. We're already doing the work. And we're committed to serving Superior for the long run.
Read our latest annual water quality report.

